Text and Photos
by Larry
Benicewicz

SEARCHING FOR
BLUES’ MISSING LINK
IN LUMBERTON

 


My mission was to accompany as scribe Guy Fay, talent scout and newly christened cinematographer for DixieFrog records of France, in his quest to record on video for a future documentary American roots music; particularly that type which establishes a link between Native American music with that of our African-American forebears.
Our destination was
Lumberton, NC, near the South Carolina border where today live the remnants of the original Tuscarora tribe, which here at one time had proliferated before the arrival of the British colonists, who then proceeded to encroach on their territory and thus precipitated the Tuscarora War of 1711-13.



But now, regardless of their origin, these inhabitants of Lumberton (including the Tuscaroras) are all often lumped together as Lumbees, so named after the nearby Lumber (or Lumbee) River. But this is a misnomer. As far as Bureau of Indian Affairs in Washington is concerned, the Lumbees are a mixture of European Americans, African Americans, and Native Americans. In 1956, the House of Representatives passed a bill, HR 4656, better known as the Lumbee Act, which acknowledged the Lumbee as a Native American tribe. However, as a consequence, this law not only denied the aid that comes with full status as a federally recognized tribe but also revoked the eligibility to re-apply for federal recognition.

By all accounts, the indigenous Tuscarora of that long ago era were amiable, passive, and peace-loving people. Their name is derived from the word “skarureh,” or “harvesters of hemp,” obtained from the ubiquitous milkweed plant which was then used to make rope, cloth, and ceremonial objects.


By 1940 there were 400 Tuscaroras living on their 6,249 acre New York state reservation, called the Tuscarora Reservation; there were 400 Tuscaroras living among the Six Nations of the Grand River in Ontario. Today the Six Nations territory has been reduced to about 44,000 acres in Tuscarora Township of the County of Brant.

Location, 1997:

Tuscarora Reservation, New York
Six Nations of the Grand River, Ontario
Tuscarora Tribe of North Carolina, Pembroke, North Carolina



















As time wore on, these farmers and hunters were gradually backed into a corner to fight for their homeland. It is not within the scope of this article to discuss the complete history of the plundering, the ghastly atrocities committed, and broken treaties with the natives - methods employed here but were all too typical of nearly all European settlers in their inexorable drive westward to the mountains. Suffice it to say that these Tuscaroras ultimately lost and were driven off their lands and the bulk of these fugitives headed to what would become western New York state and Ontario. Seeking asylum, they joined the Iroquois League or Confederacy (since they spoke a language cognate with those of this linguistic group) of Five Nations - Mohawk, Seneca, Oneida, Cayuga, and Onondaga. Today these long-term allies call themselves the Haudenosaunee (“people of the longhouse”) or Six Nations.

Many of the Tuscarora survivors left in North Carolina or those who tried to return were enslaved by the Red Coats and toiled on the tobacco farms elbow to elbow with their black counterparts. Ironically, the Cherokees, yet another Iroquois tribe of the same region were allowed to possess their own African-American slaves. Thus, over the years, there has been a great deal of intermarriage and cultural interaction between the races. So, it was only natural that musicologists would suspect that their music exhibit indications of this cross-fertilization. Indeed, there have been many black blues, R&B, and jazz musicians who also have had a Native American heritage, including Charley Patton, Scrapper Blackwell, Eddie “The Chief” Clearwater, Jimi Hendrix, Tina Turner, Chaka Khan, Little Richard, and, as Tim Duffy of Music Maker Relief Foundation points out, Thelonius Monk, Duke Ellington, and Lena Horne. Even many Creole musicians of the zydeco realm have claimed a decidedly Indian ancestry - Roy Carrier, Boozoo Chavis, and Fernest Arceneaux. And one of the up-and-coming stars, Rhiannon Giddens, of the retro jug band from Chapel Hill, the Carolina Chocolate Drops (another Music Maker find), proudly affirms her Occoneechee provenance.

But even closer to home, there was the famed five Chavis Brothers band, which recorded for Clock, Ascot, Coral, and Parkway records (all now collector’s items) and were a fixture in the Mid-Atlantic for three decades, playing all genres of music including rockabilly, R&B, and C&W. In the 60s, they held court, along with Ronnie Dove (another local celebrity), at the Band Box on Charles St between Preston and Mount Royal. In fact, I met my longtime significant other, Carol, at one of their last, long-term venues - the Park Lounge (now defunct) in Brooklyn Park, just two blocks from the house where I spent all my formative years. In the 80s, after the dissolution of the group, the leader and vocalist, Danny, went on to become a much sought after Elvis impersonator, performing at the Stardust on Pulaski Highway, just outside of Baltimore.

During my life, I had heard much of Lumberton, NC, since a good proportion of the impoverished population there had migrated north to Baltimore to secure jobs during and after World War II. I taught many of their children and recognized their familiar surnames - Locklear, Chavis, Youngbar, Oxendine, Lowery, and Deese. But I had never visited the community just off of Interstate 95, which includes the nearby towns of Maxton, Red Springs, and Pembroke in Robeson County.

Luckily for Guy and I, we had an “in,” a tour guide and ambassador of goodwill in the area, Marc Deese, the director of the Tuscarora Deer Clan Project (the tribe is divided into seven clans or families, including the Bear, Bird, Wolf, Turtle, Beaver and, Snipe). Marc and a close associate, David Locklear, appeared as backup vocalists on blues slide guitarist/singer, Pura Fe’s CD, Follow Your Heart’s Desire, for the aforementioned Tim Duffy, a project which appears in a slightly different configuration, Tuscarora Nation Blues, for its distributor in France, DixieFrog, run by Philippe Langlois of Retheuil. By the way, on both albums, Cool John Ferguson, yet another Music Maker artist of note, provides an excellent, sympathetic guitar accompaniment.


Pura Fe (meaning “pure faith” in Spanish) has an interesting biography to say the least.
Born in New York City in 1959 of a Puerto Rican/Corsican/Spanish/Taino father and a Tuscarora mother, she is a teacher, actress, and staunch activist for Indian causes, as well as a superb singer and instrumentalist. She is also the founder of the world renowned native a cappella trio, Ulali, which has toured extensively. Both Tim Duffy and Pura Fe had given Guy Fay their whole hearted approval to proceed in this film endeavor.

We found our contact in Lumberton, Marc, to be a tall, gentle giant of a man, who is friendly and hospitable, yet serious and reserved. It would be up to him whether or not he would introduce us to the secret and sacred rituals of his people. Nonetheless, our initial rendezvous was rather prosaic - the parking lot of a local McDonald’s. But the two of us must have passed muster, for no other reasons than in our earnestness and enthusiasm to learn about the tribal traditions, since he soon directed us to follow him first to his house, where he picked up his authentic costume, and then to the compound, which was nearby but well obscured by the woods.

We couldn’t have found this outpost on our own, not if we tried. Among the buildings was a museum emblazoned all around with Tuscarora symbolism, a community hall, a longhouse constructed of logs which served as a place of worship, and a ceremonial staging area; the interiors of these latter two were off-limits as far as photography was concerned. But needless to say, we still felt privileged and grateful for the opportunity of visiting this hallowed ground. For no tourists would be allowed to venture here, even if they were to stumble upon it by accident.

Guy interviewed Marc in front of the longhouse, the traditional gathering place of the clan, where he related to us a brief history of his people. Thereafter, he expressed his anxiousness for the future; whether the traditions and rituals of his tribe would survive in this era when everything seemed inevitably heading toward homogeneity. Actually this loss of identity is common worry of any ethnic minority. But here the fear was more real, because of the lack of any government acceptance of his tribe as a separate entity. As far as the U.S. is concerned, or even North Carolina for that matter, this Tuscarora Nation, unlike its namesake in the Six Nations - which is sanctioned, is self governing, is well delineated, and has a protected reservation - had no right to exist. Whatever treaties had existed before, the powers that be in Washington, for some reason or the other, chose to ignore them. Yet, the Cherokees, who were mostly banished or brutally removed from North Carolina in 1838, won this struggle and currently enjoy reaping the economic benefits of a casino near Charlotte and the Seminoles to the south in Florida, recently entangled in the lobbyist Jack Abramoff scandal, just acquired all the Hard Rock Café franchises worldwide for nearly a billion dollars. I told Marc that these locals in this rural farming district certainly seem to possess all the physical characteristics of classic Native Americans - the high cheekbones, the oriental features, like the distinguishing epicanthus, and many with jet black, straight hair. Yet it seemed a puzzle as to why they haven’t been accorded a similar position. Marc just shrugged. It obviously had a lot to do with politics and money. But he expressed his determination to right these old wrongs despite the odds (the aforementioned Lumbee Act disallowed any Tuscarora petitions to be reviewed) and to continue the struggle for independence. Then he surrendered the floor, in reality the ground, to Willie “Bee” Locklear.





Willie “Bee” Locklear, the Bear Clan chief, explained that he served as an elder in the tribe, an unofficial advisor or counselor; maybe even at times an arbiter in disputes, but only if both the dissenting parties sought him out voluntarily. Actually, Willie at first seemed reticent to speak, as if suspicious of our motives. Maybe he thought that we were the FBI, because of the sheer number of questions we directed his way. And I have to admit that we put him on the spot because we did not know a lot about his customs. One question in particular - how the Tuscaroras were able to reconcile their former religious beliefs with their relatively recent espousal of Christianity - disturbed him, as if he had to justify defending his faith. “Let’s put it this way,” he said, “There’s only one Great Spirit.” It was a brilliant response - simple and to the point.

But Willie eventually warmed up to me, especially when I talked of the Chavis Brothers, his former idols as well. I discovered that in 1964 Willie had lived for several months in Baltimore, performing as keyboardist in the short lived “Soul Drifters,” whose regular Broadway haunt he just couldn’t recall. And he also handled the piano chores in the well traveled Tarheel Rockers during that same period.

Willie was an expert in all the traditional food dishes, including those requiring vegetables like corn, beans, and squash, and meats, like deer, rabbit, and squirrel. In fact, each year among the tribesmen there is an organized, ceremonial bear hunt. He informed us that besides water, some of the conventional Tuscarora beverages included huckleberry and blueberry drunk from homemade gourds. And, of course, there was cornbread to accompany meals, not only a staple of their diet but also another uniquely Indian creation.

It was getting dark, so Marc ushered us into the community center, which also served as a school. In fact, there was a display of the Tuscarora alphabet, as well as the drawings and corresponding names of all the clans in that language. Also in the interior, was hanging the elaborate tribal flag, which I was forbidden to photograph. Guy claims that the state flag of New Mexico was thus stolen from an original design by the Navajo Indians. And perhaps it was for this reason that I was denied the right to shoot it.

Inside, David Locklear, the “faith keeper” of the Deer Clan, also talked about importance of preserving their heritage and to this end volunteers as the local language instructor. He finds it very encouraging that youngsters are attending his classes in increasing numbers. Before him, it was Pura Fe who assumed this role in this very building before going out on the road to forge her career. As this article is being written, she’s in France performing before huge sold-out arenas.

By the way, Marc, himself, is a teacher of sorts and has a government funded contract in helping such young Native Americans to deal with issues such as low self esteem, substance abuse, displacement, and even the idea of genocide. Prejudice against Indians is far from dead in these parts. And it’s had a demoralizing effect on more than a few of these residents. In fact, the local chapter of the Ku Klux Klan has had a long, violent history of harassing these people whom they disparagingly regard as “mongrels.”

As time was really flying by now, Marc suggested that we get to the task at hand - to determine whether there was indeed a relationship between the music, the primitive blues of the black ancestors and that of the Indians. David grabbed a tom-tom (officially called a water drum) and sat on the couch and was soon joined by Trey Locklear with a rattle and Marc. Marc believes that the “heartbeat rhythm” typical of many Tuscarora songs eventually may have evolved into the blues shuffle and asked me to listen for it. They all sang a few traditional pieces but I didn’t understand what he meant until I heard “Stomp Dance,” perhaps their fourth number. Then it all came together. It was that familiar call and response interplay of work songs which developed into gospel. They were actually chanting what I interpreted as field hollers and I could hardly tell whether it was black in origin or Native American. And moreover, it had a lot of soul. What an amazing revelation. After having heard this one random selection, I’d have to go back and reexamine everything I learned about the true source of blues music.

Marc had several more surprises planned for us that evening and urged us to hit the trail, but we first had to prevail upon him to don his full Indian regalia which he exhibits during concerts, like New Orleans’ JazzFest, where the group has been invited. Not to be outdone, and unbeknown to us, another spectator, Hazel Bryant, came out of hiding to proudly display her handiwork, an elegant, embroidered, traditional dress befitting a person of her stature in the tribe. Her Indian name, Teskiea, means that she “knows the medicines,” all the herbal cures. But finally it was time to go.

As we were now pressed for time, Marc, in fact, had to cancel some of the stops on his itinerary, but he wasn’t going to let us go without giving us a few more examples of Indian music upon which to ruminate. After traveling seemingly for miles and miles in the darkness, we arrived at the modest home, way out in the sticks, of Sarah F. Locklear. I have to admit that I was a little uncomfortable about barging in on this sweet middle age woman, especially after she told us that she had just lost her much beloved mother just a week earlier and yet to a potential malpractice case as well. There was so much sadness in the air in that household, or maybe anger mixed with grief, that it was palpable. But Sarah, a widow, was obviously a strong woman whose faith sustains her, and wanted to keep her promise to Mark (whom she trusted unconditionally) to sing examples of spiritual music with her sisters. Unfortunately, one was sick and couldn’t attend, but the other, Pearl, was ready to begin as a duet. When they sang in English a gospel hymn dedicated to their mother, it was so moving and heartfelt that it brought me to tears. I thought to myself - if this isn’t soul music or music from the soul, what is?

As I remained there for a while, I became more comfortable, feeling less and less like an intruder and Sarah and I discussed the possibility of bringing legal action against the hospital that suddenly and without explanation “took” her mom. She was curious about Baltimore and asked me if I knew about the Chavis brothers, her cousins. In fact, she related that Danny had since “gotten religion” and quit Baltimore and had returned to his old homestead not that far away. She was surprised that I knew all their names and songs. But no one was more astonished than I. Here I was a million miles from nowhere  in the middle of a huge field and there was but one degree of separation between us. Unbelievable.

It was now about nine o’clock, and we wanted to politely and respectfully beg off from the tour, since we hadn’t yet found a hotel room nor eaten and we were still miles from Lumberton. But Marc, anticipating our reluctance, scheduled yet another audition, all the while assuring us of its convenience. It would be on the way back to the interstate and at his brother’s state-of-the-art chiropractic office no less, the interior of which, for our needs, acoustically rang like a bell. A few minutes later, the petite, perky and comely Charly Lowry pulled up and popped out of her car. At 23, she’s already had her Warholian “15 minutes,” having been one of the finalists in the third installment of the popular American Idol TV program, wherein she tackled Aretha Franklin’s “Chain of Fools,” and then lost to Fantasia, the ultimate victor. I confessed to never having watched the show and regarded the contestants rather contemptuously as no more than amateur karaoke singers. But, in her case, I have to say that I was deeply impressed. She not only had credentials - she graduated from the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill - but also she was well versed in American soul music from the 60s - the Temptations, Four Tops, and Otis Redding. Moreover, she was writing her own material. In fact, she sang an original composition regarding bigotry and bias against Indians, “Brown Girl,” accompanying herself with these odd little cans filled with pebbles with which she kept time. For her age, she’s cool, calm, and collected and definitely has her act together, including acquiring the publishing on her songs. She’s ambitious and I predict that we’ll hear from her again.



As far back as early 1700, one of the first reports about the Tuscaroras came from a Mr. Lawson, the Surveyor General of North Carolina, who actually lived among the tribe from time to time. In describing these people, he commented that “they were really better to us than we have been to them, as they always give freely of their victuals at their quarters, while we let them walk by our doors hungry and do not relieve them.” And here it was three centuries later that Marc and his companion, Brittany Simmons, offered us - complete strangers - food and lodging for that night. We would have gladly accepted this offer from our gracious host, had we not had to drive back to Baltimore the next day. And I think he understood all the ramifications of us staying with him that night. In other words, it would have been impossible for us to get an early start - breakfast, another round of performers, more discussions, more questions, etc. Nonetheless, he was still very reluctant to cut us loose.

As it was, the evening couldn’t have ended more perfectly. We got back to I-95 in time to find a reasonable hotel and a steakhouse that had beers on tap. And as we digested our meal and the events of the past day, we wondered if there was in existence a pure thread of any form of music. We certainly had a lot to ponder regarding the true origin of the blues. Could it have been conceived by the American Indians? On our own continent and not, as generally assumed, in Africa? Without a doubt, after this experience, this issue would indeed be food for thought.

Larry Benicewicz, Baltimore Blues Society
P.S.: The Pura Fe CD entitled Follow Your Heart’s Desire can be obtained in the U.S. through Music Maker at info@musicmaker.org  and Tuscarora Nation Blues, on DixieFrog, recent winner of the prestigious Prix de L’Academie du Jazz, can be purchased through www.bluesweb.com
more info:
www.peace4turtleisland.org/pages/tuscarora.htm
www.tuscaroras.com
Worldcopyright © 1998-2007 BluesArtStudio, Blues Life, USA, AUSTRIA